By order of 17 March 2015, the Court of Monza took a clear position on the procedure of preventive technical expert opinion (consulenza tecnica preventiva) for the purposes of settling a dispute, holding as fully admissible the application pursuant to Article 696 bis of the Code of Civil Procedure (c.p.c.) filed by a corporate current-account holder against a bank.

The ruling is of considerable interest because – drawing on numerous recent judicial precedents – it addresses in detail all the points of law that allow (and indeed recommend) the use of this procedure also in the context of banking relationships, for disputes concerning the challenge of unlawful charges (usurious interest and compound interest, overdraft commissions, fictitious value dates, etc.).

In particular, the President of the Court – after pointing out that the applicant’s action is aimed precisely at verifying the unlawfulness of charges in the account statements and that, therefore, the claim may be classed among the “claims arising from the non-performance or defective performance of contractual obligations or from tort” provided for in Article 696 bis c.p.c. – rightly observes that the very deflationary function of the instrument (that is, reducing the burden on the courts), combined with its purpose of preventive taking of evidence, does not allow excessively formalistic and restrictive interpretations, as recognised by the persuasive approach of other Courts.

Equally noteworthy is the reasoning by which the further objection of inadmissibility raised by the respondent Bank was rejected: the Court held that an application pursuant to Article 696 bis c.p.c. may also be admitted where the current-account relationship is still open, given that – in this case – “the customer’s interest is normally satisfied by recalculating the actual balance, net of the void charges” and, in this regard, “a claim for nullity may always be brought even while the relationship is ongoing “


Attachments



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *