The tax authorities cannot second-guess the entrepreneur’s business strategies and the costs incurred, thereby denying their deductibility. This is the important conclusion reached by the Supreme Court (Corte di Cassazione) in judgment no. 10319 of 20 May 2015.

The justices base their reasoning on the point that, as regards income tax, the powers of the tax authorities do include assessing the reasonableness of costs and revenues shown in the financial statements and tax returns, and denying, where appropriate, the deductibility of part of a cost that is disproportionate to revenues or to the company’s business purpose, but such scrutiny cannot extend to objectively verifying the appropriateness of that particular cost in relation to the business.

The Supreme Court thus dismisses the appeal brought by the Revenue Agency (Agenzia delle Entrate) against the judgment of the Regional Tax Commission of Lombardy, which had annulled an assessment notice for VAT, IRPEG (corporate income tax) and IRAP (regional business tax) purposes for the 1999 tax year, by which the Office had denied the deductibility of the costs arising from the supply contract in place between the taxpayer company

In other words, the Revenue Agency challenged a supply contract signed between companies belonging to the same group.

The tax section explains that, for a cost incurred by the entrepreneur to be deductible from business income, it is sufficient that it be related to the business as such, for the purpose of carrying out an activity that is inherent and suited to generating profits.

The Supreme Court upholds the contested ruling, considering it in line with the principles governing the scope of the powers of the tax authorities, which do not include scrutiny aimed at verifying the necessity and/or appropriateness of costs in relation to the business purpose. Such a check would amount to assessments of commercial strategy, reserved to the entrepreneur and, as such, not open to challenge.



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *