With the third corrective decree to the Italian Insolvency Code (Legislative Decree 136/2024), Article 22(1)(a) of the Code (CCII) was rewritten: the aim was to widen, through the wording “financing in any form”, the range of arrangements eligible for pre-deductible status in negotiated composition. Shortly after its entry into force, however, that wording is producing the opposite of the intended effect: it has not removed the uncertainties of application, it has opened up new ones. The courts of first instance are reading it in divergent ways, and anyone negotiating financial support for a company in negotiated composition must today reckon with a far from stable framework.
The divergences concern two distinct questions.
What falls within the notion of “financing”
For the Court of Milan (decision of 2 May 2026), pre-deduction remains a benefit that is “typical and exhaustive”: no extensive interpretation. It follows that the provision protects only genuine financial credit – money made available or guarantees granted – while a payment extension granted by a supplier is left outside. The reasoning of the Milan judges does not deny that, from an economic standpoint, a payment extension produces cash-flow relief comparable to that of a loan; it asserts, however, its different legal nature, that of an exchange relationship rather than a credit relationship.
The practical consequence is of direct concern to anyone negotiating payment terms with a company in negotiated composition: a supplier who grants generous extensions, counting on pre-deductible status equivalent to that of a true lender, may find itself without protection if the court seised follows the Milan approach.
Who may provide finance with pre-deductible status
On the second point – the subjective standing of the provider – the same Court of Milan has adopted a selective criterion: only “supervised” entities, or in any event those ordinarily authorised to extend credit, may benefit from pre-deduction; every other form of financial support remains excluded.
The position already expressed by the Court of Vasto (decree of 5 February 2025) points the other way: according to this reading, the entrepreneur may obtain authorisation to enter into pre-deductible financing even with third parties lacking specialist qualifications, provided that the transaction is the result of a private negotiation and that the order specifies its nature and purpose in terms of business continuity and the best satisfaction of creditors. The Court of Naples, on 8 April 2025, takes the same line for shareholder loans: no 80% cap (unlike in the concordato preventivo, the pre-insolvency composition with creditors) and full pre-deductibility notwithstanding the ordinary subordination, precisely because otherwise those claims would remain subordinated by law.
Two readings, two pools of financiers
This is not a dispute for insiders only: the outcome determines who, in practice, can structure a new-finance operation alongside a company in difficulty with reasonable certainty of being repaid on a pre-deductible basis. If the Milan approach becomes established, the range of “eligible” financiers narrows to supervised intermediaries alone, and a private debt fund, an industrial investor or even a shareholder acting outside this perimeter risks a weak pre-deductible status, open to challenge in any subsequent liquidation phase. If the Vasto and Naples approaches prevail, the range of eligible parties remains as wide as the wording of the provision would suggest.
In the absence, for now, of a ruling from the Court of Cassation guiding uniform interpretation, or in any event of settled practice among the specialised divisions, the most prudent course is to build every financing operation in negotiated composition around an application for authorisation that documents precisely the nature, purpose and functionality of the intervention in relation to the restructuring plan – regardless of who the lender is. It is the only way, at present, not to leave the fate of pre-deduction in the hands of the approach taken by the court that may be called upon, if necessary, to assess it after the event.
Source: T. Nigro, “Giudici divisi sui «finanziamenti in qualsiasi forma» nella composizione negoziata”, Eutekne.info, 21 July 2026; Court of Milan, 2 May 2026; Court of Vasto (decree), 5 February 2025; Court of Naples, Civil Division VII, 8 April 2025.


Leave a Reply